Episode 182: Games Court – Big Sammy European Extreme Edition
The worst format in podcasting is back! For the first time since 2021, Samuel runs his pre-owned purchases past Judge Castle.
The worst format in podcasting is back! For the first time since 2021, Samuel runs his pre-owned purchases past Judge Castle.
With a hangover from ninety June livestreams, Matthew and Samuel each deliver their ten favourites from the hype season.
Retro Gamer editor Darran Jones steps into the draft dojo to celebrate Sony’s first gaming handheld device.
Hear about James’ journey from comic book artist during Marvel’s bankruptcy to becoming a key editor on a host of important media outlets throughout the ’00s.
We each try and guess five mystery games based on snippets from their reviews in ’00s games magazines. Feel free to play along!
Two Giant Men, 20 categories, dubious rules! Time for another draft episode, this time on the subject of video game soundtracks.
Here’s what we’ve been playing lately: Stellar Blade, Animal Well, Octopath Traveler 2, Dark Forces Remaster and Pepper Grinder.
Matthew speaks to one of his favourite authors, Stuart Turton. Hear about his exhausting creative process, and what it takes to write a novel.
This week’s guest is Rachel Weber, who probably has the most varied and fascinating career in games media of anyone who’s appeared on the podcast so far.
The worst format in British podcasting returns.
The best games of 2003, and loads of bullshit about Matthew’s mini-fridge and Samuel’s week of work experience in the fire brigade.
What we’ve been playing lately, including Dragon’s Dogma 2, Helldivers 2, Rise of the Ronin, Stellar Blade and some old Command & Conquer nonsense.
Former PC Gamer Senior Reporter Steven Messner is our guest this week! Hear about his epic reports of goings on in EVE Online and other MMOs.
Matthew played 70 hours of FF7 Rebirth, while Samuel played a measly 14 hours. How’s it going so far?
This week’s guest is former Edge editor Alex Wiltshire. Hear about his era of the magazine, as well as his time working at Hello Games and Mojang.
Matthew has finally become a big FF7 head, ploughing through Remake in January and now being 50 hours deep into Rebirth.
Time for our first draft episode of 2024! It’s the turn of the PlayStation, one of the most important consoles in history.
After some dense episodes, allow us this brief respite to answer a slew of listener questions.
Beloved guest Jeremy Peel drops by.
Two top 10 lists of our favourite games from 2002 and a slew of ridiculous anecdotes about working in Homebase and studying GCSE Drama.
Returning guest Ashley Day tells us about his love of the Sega Saturn, then gives us his ten favourite Sega games of all time.
Some nutritious games waffle to cancel out last week’s nonsense mailbag episode.
After several solid episodes in a row, The Back Page crashes down to Earth. But you do get to hear about the famous person Matthew went to school with…
After last week’s belting return with the GOTY episode, it’s time we roll out some bullshit gaming predictions for 2024.
Our biggest episode of the year is here! Two top 10 lists of the best games of the year.
A fun holiday special to see out the year – featuring special guests, our favourite Christmas-themed games and the Back Page alternative GOTY awards.
It’s Matthew’s first time through the original Final Fantasy 7.
Samuel and Matthew compete to pick the best selection of 10 licensed games, and discuss the wildly inconsistent history of licensed games.
The latest on what we’ve been playing, featuring Alan Wake 2, Chants of Sennaar, Super Mario Wonder and more.
Comedian, writer and streaming superstar Ellie Gibson talks us through her career at Eurogamer during the heyday of the PS3 and 360 era of games media.
A deep dive on the year’s biggest PlayStation game with Dave Scarborough, sometime features editor of gamesTM.
IGN’s Simon Cardy joins us to celebrate the history of Remedy’s games, including Max Payne, Alan Wake and even Quantum Break.
Rob Pearson of PlayStation Access is our guest this week. Hear about Rob’s unusual journey to YouTube fame via print media.
From GTA 3 to Silent Hill 2, 2001 was one of the best years in the history of games. We also share many pointless details of our mixed fortunes as teenagers.
We’ve firmly entered silly season, and Matthew has finished Cyberpunk 2077: Phantom Liberty. Does it change his take on the CD Projekt RED FPS/RPG?
People Can Fly’s Jamie Smith tells us about his career and things you only realise about games when you actually make them for a living.
We’ve each played 25 hours of Starfield – here’s what we thought.
Happy, you sickos? It’s the latest entry in our bizarre Games Court format. Those found guilty will die…by Pikmin.
Matthew and Samuel compete to pick the 15 best Nintendo DS games – after an extremely long preamble.
Matthew has played 10 hours of Sea of Stars, so we discuss that, the Doom mod My House, Armored Core 6, Paranormasight and Dredge.
It’s fun for the first hour, it sags in the second, but gets it back just at the end. A 6/10 episode.
We count down the best games of 2016, a year that brought good news for everyone! Except Microsoft. And Nintendo.
With Baldur’s Gate 3 taking over the world, genre expert Jeremy Peel returns to discuss how RPGs have evolved since the days of the Infinity Engine games.
A simple but cheerful ‘what we’ve been playing’ joint this week, featuring Exoprimal, Telltale’s comeback game The Expanse, 1998’s Parasite Eve and Pikmin 4.
Former Edge editor Margaret Robertson joins us to discuss working on the magazine from 2003-2007 and her career in game development. It’s a good one.
Matthew and Samuel compete to pick the best 10 games (and one HD collection) that represent the PS3’s somewhat inconsistent library.
Kick back, take a seat! Pour yourself a tall glass of water. It’s a simple update on what we’ve been playing lately, featuring Final Fantasy 16 and BG3.
Our guest this week is PC Gamer Senior Editor Wes Fenlon, who talks to us about his career, his newsletter, and Nintendo during the GameCube/GBA era.
Two large gentlemen replay MGS3 and discuss where the upcoming remake could make improvements. Then, we rank the bosses of this all-time classic.
Samuel and Matthew revisit the classic Square Enix/Squaresoft RPG series this week. Well, the bits they know about, anyway.
From Doordash ads to a game that looks 90% like BioShock Infinite, these were our highlights from the past week of game reveals.
Edge Deputy Editor Chris Schilling joins us for this week’s episode. And yes: we talk about what it means when Edge awards a game a 10.
Is the Xbox 360 the greatest console ever made? And remember, it’s just a bit of fun! Except where we take what the other person says very personally.
More listeners’ pre-owned purchases go on trial in this latest version of the much-despised Games Court podcast format. Enjoy, and deepest apologies.
Matthew has played 40 hours of the new Zelda, Samuel has played 10. How are they getting on?
Everything except Zelda is discussed in this week’s episode!
Monster collecting RPG Cassette Beasts just launched! To celebrate, returning pod guest Jay Baylis talks us through the creation of the game.
Matthew and Rich Stanton build a hall of fame from Resident Evil creator Shinji Mikami’s body of work.
Two top 10s of 2015’s greatest games. Hear about Matthew and Samuel’s friendship emerging during a press trip to Germany.
Samuel assembles a power ranking of the video games based on the Star Wars movies, and Matthew politely humours him for two hours.
In this week’s episode, Samuel suffers from jetlag and Matthew suffers from living as we recount what we’ve been playing lately.
We’ve both finished Resident Evil 4 Remake, which is out now! The original was an era-defining game for us, so what’s the deal with this one?
Will Porter, former PC Zone editor turned game developer, is our guest this week.
Matthew and Samuel compete to pick the 10 best Capcom games from the developer/publisher’s extensive and dazzling library.
Matthew fires through a whole bunch of recommendations to check out on 3DS and Wii U before their respective eShops close.
Our task this week is to construct a 10-game hall of fame (or perhaps hall of infamy?) for the Nintendo Wii U.
We go deep on The Last of Us. We recall our original thoughts on the game from back in 2013 and give our verdict on the HBO show so far.
Former ONM editor and Mobilegamer.biz founder Neil Long is this week’s guest.
Hi-Fi Rush, GoldenEye 007 and Fire Emblem: Engage are among the games we’ve been playing lately.
Two top 10 lists from 2014. Expect a mixture of mag recollections and deep analysis of the games that mattered.
Our most interminable podcast format, Games Court, returns! Sorry again for the continued existence of Games Court.
From Indiana Jones to a Nintendo Switch successor, it’s time for 23 more ridiculous predictions founded on no basis of fact whatsoever.
Samuel was suffering with Covid during this episode, so it’s a slightly gentler one than normal.
2022 was undoubtedly a blockbuster-deprived year, but it was still a strong 12 months for games in many other ways.
We each try to assemble the ‘dream’ RPG party across 14 categories. Predictably, we each created nightmares instead.
Andy Kelly is back to discuss his exit from games media after 18 years – and to share eight review scores he got slightly wrong.
We revisit our 22 predictions from the start of the year to see just how wrong we were.
Matthew and Samuel both played God of War Ragnarök. But Matthew actually finished it!
Samuel finally played Cyberpunk 2077 properly, and had a (mostly) good time!
A Plague Tale: Requiem, FF7 Remake, Stay Out Of The House and Taiji are among the games discussed.
Ahead of the release of Ragnarök, we rank all the God of War games from 2005’s original up to the 2018 PS4 entry.
The wonderful 101st episode of The Back Page attempts to build a 5-game hall of fame from the entire PlatinumGames catalogue.
It’s a clip show. Enjoy the clips.
Lucy Blundell joins us to discuss one of Matthew’s favourite genres: the (usually) non-horny visual novel.
We’re joined by Ben Hanson of MinnMax on this episode, who shares a bunch of great stories from his many years making videos.
A grim fate awaits anyone who gets on the wrong side of Judge Big Sammy.
From The Getaway to Sleeping Dogs, this week Judge Matthew Castle puts the open world games that followed in GTA 3’s wake on trial.
We try to boil down the complete library of Lucasarts adventure games into five representative titles.
Matthew talks us through his many hours agonising over a Splatoon 3 review.
Saints Row, Arcade Paradise, Ryse: Son of Rome, Splatoon 3, Star Wars: Rogue Squadron and Escape Academy are the games discussed.
It’s draft revenge time! Who can pick the 10 best games released during the years 2000-2005?
Hear what goes into an Edge 10, as well as thoughts on Destiny, E3, Street Fighter and the world of videogame consulting.
Guess the game based on quotes taken from ’90s games magazines.
Is Valve’s handheld PC all it’s cracked up to be? Yes!
Katharine Castle rejoins us to discuss the Xenoblade Chronicles series in enormous detail.
Two top 10 lists of the best games of 2013, in our usual style.
We undertake another grand project: building a library of the very best games for the Nintendo Switch.
Xenoblade Chronicles 3, Hyrule Warriors: Age of Calamity, Sniper Elite 5 and TMNT: Shredder’s Revenge are discussed.
This time Judge Big Sammy is making the verdicts.
Hate Destiny? Fair enough! You may still enjoy the first 24 minutes of this podcast.
We count down our 10 personal most anticipated games, based on whatever E3 was this year.
Samuel and Matthew each compete to pick the 10 best PC games released in the years 1990 to 1999.
Andy Kelly joins us to discuss his love of Sega’s Dreamcast, and his new Alien: Isolation book, Perfect Organism.
The Centennial Case, Tunic, Gears Tactics, Eternal Threads and Little Cities are among the games we discuss.
Get ready for another top-drawer story about Hideo Kojima.
Samuel catalogues the Star Wars games that exist between simple notions like light and dark – these are the 6 and 7/10 Star Wars games.
Former Edge editor Jen Simpkins joins us to discuss some highlights of her career.
It’s probably too long, yet again, but it covers everything from our favourite TV genres to trends in games that we miss.
Hopefully you’ll agree we do Max justice.
Another round of indie game recommendations – and 20 minutes of very welcome Dragon’s Dogma chat.
Two top 10 lists of the best games of 2012, in our usual style. Enjoy!
The top 5 Kirby games, and detailed thoughts on Kirby and the Forgotten Land for Nintendo Switch.
Ghostwire: Tokyo, Kirby and the Forgotten Land, Tunic, Marvel’s Guardians of the Galaxy and Monster Train.
Matthew and Samuel compete to build the best library for Sony’s fan-favourite handheld device.
Judge Castle returns to decide whether listeners must die.
Samuel and Matthew have played Elden Ring for a combined 37 hours – here’s what they think so far.
Matthew’s seen the Uncharted movie, which is a nice excuse for a deep dive into one of our favourite PlayStation series.
Jon Hicks, formerly of Official Xbox Magazine, joins us to revisit the 360 era.
Matthew Castle Productions and Big Sammy Holdings are each taking on Game Pass. Who built the best gaming subscription service?
Dying Light 2, Windjammers 2, Resident Evil 4 VR, NEO: The World Ends With You and more.
Jay Baylis joins us to discuss the long history of Pokémon games, subjecting Matthew to his idea of torture.
25 of your questions about gaming (yes, and Bath restaurants) answered.
Matthew and Samuel compete to pick the 10 best Wii games.
11 predictions for the year ahead in gaming, all based on absolutely no information whatsoever.
Our GOTY episode is here!
We revisit every game based on the films from Peter Jackson.
We put ourselves on trial, discussing everything from N64 games on Switch to PS5 haptics.
Luigi’s Mansion 3, Resident Evil 3 Remake and more.
Samuel ranks the seven mainline Halo games to date, and both Samuel and Matthew weigh in on the wonders of Halo Infinite multiplayer.
Who can build the best hypothetical mini console, Matthew, representing GameCube, or Samuel, representing the original Xbox?
A year that brought us Batman: Arkham City, Skyrim and The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword.
Rich Stanton joins us to discuss the game’s themes and legacy as a PS2 classic.
Matthew and Samuel talk through the entire process of making a games magazine from start to finish.
Louise Blain joins us to pick out 15 cool spooky games, from Eternal Darkness to Silent Hill 4: The Room.
Steve Burns joins us to discuss Grand Theft Auto III.
Tamoor Hussain helps us rank the Batman: Arkham games.
Who will live and who will die?
Hear how Simon broke the news of Hideo Kojima’s departure from Konami.
Matthew and Samuel each compete to pick the 10 best games on the system for a hypothetical N64 Mini console.
We’ve finished Deathloop! Hear about the history of the immersive sim.
2010, one of the best years of gaming in modern memory.
Judge Matthew Castle will decide if defendant Samuel Roberts lives or dies.
Plus: another baffling listener question about Yuji Naka.
Dan Dawkins joins us to discuss his long history in games media.
What if Sony released a PS2 Mini? And what if it was good?
From The Last of Us Part 2 to Neo: The World Ends With You and Crimson Skies: High Road to Revenge.
Matthew reels off the 10 best entries in this immortal Capcom visual novel series.
Big Sammy Holdings and Matthew Castle Productions are moving into the hardware market.
Matthew has played The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword HD. Does he still think it’s worth an Edge 10 a decade later?
From Uncharted 2 to Batman: Arkham Asylum.
How do you write about a game that’s not actually finished yet?
Please don’t unsubscribe!
E3 2021 is finally over!
Keza MacDonald kindly joins us on this episode to discuss her long career, and whether E3 still matters in 2021.
We’re answering 22 more of your questions.
Matthew and Samuel can each pick 6 game developers to build a new publisher.
What makes a great detective game?
We’re revisiting the original Mass Effect trilogy in this episode.
We’ve both finished Resident Evil Village.
From Dead Space to Grand Theft Auto 4, 2008 was a phenomenal year in gaming.
It’s two men, getting defensive about old review scores. What makes a better podcast than that?
Phil Savage joins us for a Yakuza-themed special episode.
10 of our best games magazine covers, and the stories of how they each got made.
Here are 10 games worth grabbing before the digital storefronts vanish forever.
It’s about 30 minutes longer than it should be.
We’re counting down the system’s best games.
Interviewing the people who make games. Are we good at it?
Samuel Roberts stands accused of crimes against good taste.
From Uncharted: Drake’s Fortune to Crackdown.
Definitely not just an excuse to hear some more of Matthew’s great Nintendo thoughts and anecdotes.
Is it better than Galaxy? Definitely not. Odyssey? Nope. But it is still pretty great.
Our two top 30 games of the generation lists conclude this week.
Two top 30 lists of the best games on PS4, Xbox One and Wii U from the past 7 or 8 years.
We’ve both played a lot of Hitman 3.
Matthew and Samuel discuss the art of making covers for games magazines.
It’s all based on very few facts.
Wow, 2020 was the worst!
Matthew discusses his 70 hours playing the glitchy but nonetheless fascinating game.
From Twilight Princess to Gears of War.
IO Interactive: nobody does it better?
What goes into awarding a game a 7/10 review score? And what happens when you get it wrong?
Two next-generation consoles just launched.
Retro Gamer editor Darran Jones steps into the draft dojo to celebrate Sony’s first gaming handheld device.
Hear about James’ journey from comic book artist during Marvel’s bankruptcy to becoming a key editor on a host of important media outlets throughout the ’00s.
Matthew speaks to one of his favourite authors, Stuart Turton. Hear about his exhausting creative process, and what it takes to write a novel.
This week’s guest is Rachel Weber, who probably has the most varied and fascinating career in games media of anyone who’s appeared on the podcast so far.
Former PC Gamer Senior Reporter Steven Messner is our guest this week! Hear about his epic reports of goings on in EVE Online and other MMOs.
This week’s guest is former Edge editor Alex Wiltshire. Hear about his era of the magazine, as well as his time working at Hello Games and Mojang.
Beloved guest Jeremy Peel drops by.
Returning guest Ashley Day tells us about his love of the Sega Saturn, then gives us his ten favourite Sega games of all time.
Comedian, writer and streaming superstar Ellie Gibson talks us through her career at Eurogamer during the heyday of the PS3 and 360 era of games media.
A deep dive on the year’s biggest PlayStation game with Dave Scarborough, sometime features editor of gamesTM.
IGN’s Simon Cardy joins us to celebrate the history of Remedy’s games, including Max Payne, Alan Wake and even Quantum Break.
Rob Pearson of PlayStation Access is our guest this week. Hear about Rob’s unusual journey to YouTube fame via print media.
People Can Fly’s Jamie Smith tells us about his career and things you only realise about games when you actually make them for a living.
With Baldur’s Gate 3 taking over the world, genre expert Jeremy Peel returns to discuss how RPGs have evolved since the days of the Infinity Engine games.
Former Edge editor Margaret Robertson joins us to discuss working on the magazine from 2003-2007 and her career in game development. It’s a good one.
Our guest this week is PC Gamer Senior Editor Wes Fenlon, who talks to us about his career, his newsletter, and Nintendo during the GameCube/GBA era.
Edge Deputy Editor Chris Schilling joins us for this week’s episode. And yes: we talk about what it means when Edge awards a game a 10.
Monster collecting RPG Cassette Beasts just launched! To celebrate, returning pod guest Jay Baylis talks us through the creation of the game.
Matthew and Rich Stanton build a hall of fame from Resident Evil creator Shinji Mikami’s body of work.
Will Porter, former PC Zone editor turned game developer, is our guest this week.
Our task this week is to construct a 10-game hall of fame (or perhaps hall of infamy?) for the Nintendo Wii U.
Former ONM editor and Mobilegamer.biz founder Neil Long is this week’s guest.
Andy Kelly is back to discuss his exit from games media after 18 years – and to share eight review scores he got slightly wrong.
Katharine Castle joins us to recount a whole host of great moments from The Legend of Zelda’s history.
Lucy Blundell joins us to discuss one of Matthew’s favourite genres: the (usually) non-horny visual novel.
We’re joined by Ben Hanson of MinnMax on this episode, who shares a bunch of great stories from his many years making videos.
From The Getaway to Sleeping Dogs, this week Judge Matthew Castle puts the open world games that followed in GTA 3’s wake on trial.
We try to boil down the complete library of Lucasarts adventure games into five representative titles.
Hear what goes into an Edge 10, as well as thoughts on Destiny, E3, Street Fighter and the world of videogame consulting.
Katharine Castle rejoins us to discuss the Xenoblade Chronicles series in enormous detail.
Rich Stanton joins us to deliver a comprehensive overview of the Metal Gear Solid series.
Hate Destiny? Fair enough! You may still enjoy the first 24 minutes of this podcast.
We count down our 10 personal most anticipated games, based on whatever E3 was this year.
Andy Kelly joins us to discuss his love of Sega’s Dreamcast, and his new Alien: Isolation book, Perfect Organism.
Get ready for another top-drawer story about Hideo Kojima.
Former Edge editor Jen Simpkins joins us to discuss some highlights of her career.
Another round of indie game recommendations – and 20 minutes of very welcome Dragon’s Dogma chat.
Jon Hicks, formerly of Official Xbox Magazine, joins us to revisit the 360 era.
Jay Baylis joins us to discuss the long history of Pokémon games, subjecting Matthew to his idea of torture.
Rich Stanton joins us to discuss the game’s themes and legacy as a PS2 classic.
Louise Blain joins us to pick out 15 cool spooky games, from Eternal Darkness to Silent Hill 4: The Room.
Steve Burns joins us to discuss Grand Theft Auto III.
Tamoor Hussain helps us rank the Batman: Arkham games.
Hear how Simon broke the news of Hideo Kojima’s departure from Konami.
We’ve finished Deathloop! Hear about the history of the immersive sim.
Plus: another baffling listener question about Yuji Naka.
Dan Dawkins joins us to discuss his long history in games media.
Please don’t unsubscribe!
What makes a great detective game?
Phil Savage joins us for a Yakuza-themed special episode.
We’re counting down the system’s best games.
Is it better than Galaxy? Definitely not. Odyssey? Nope. But it is still pretty great.
We each try and guess five mystery games based on snippets from their reviews in ’00s games magazines. Feel free to play along!
What we’ve been playing lately, including Dragon’s Dogma 2, Helldivers 2, Rise of the Ronin, Stellar Blade and some old Command & Conquer nonsense.
After some dense episodes, allow us this brief respite to answer a slew of listener questions.
After several solid episodes in a row, The Back Page crashes down to Earth. But you do get to hear about the famous person Matthew went to school with…
A fun holiday special to see out the year – featuring special guests, our favourite Christmas-themed games and the Back Page alternative GOTY awards.
The latest on what we’ve been playing, featuring Alan Wake 2, Chants of Sennaar, Super Mario Wonder and more.
We’ve firmly entered silly season, and Matthew has finished Cyberpunk 2077: Phantom Liberty. Does it change his take on the CD Projekt RED FPS/RPG?
Matthew has played 10 hours of Sea of Stars, so we discuss that, the Doom mod My House, Armored Core 6, Paranormasight and Dredge.
It’s fun for the first hour, it sags in the second, but gets it back just at the end. A 6/10 episode.
A simple but cheerful ‘what we’ve been playing’ joint this week, featuring Exoprimal, Telltale’s comeback game The Expanse, 1998’s Parasite Eve and Pikmin 4.
Kick back, take a seat! Pour yourself a tall glass of water. It’s a simple update on what we’ve been playing lately, featuring Final Fantasy 16 and BG3.
Everything except Zelda is discussed in this week’s episode!
In this week’s episode, Samuel suffers from jetlag and Matthew suffers from living as we recount what we’ve been playing lately.
Hi-Fi Rush, GoldenEye 007 and Fire Emblem: Engage are among the games we’ve been playing lately.
Samuel was suffering with Covid during this episode, so it’s a slightly gentler one than normal.
A Plague Tale: Requiem, FF7 Remake, Stay Out Of The House and Taiji are among the games discussed.
Saints Row, Arcade Paradise, Ryse: Son of Rome, Splatoon 3, Star Wars: Rogue Squadron and Escape Academy are the games discussed.
Guess the game based on quotes taken from ’90s games magazines.
Xenoblade Chronicles 3, Hyrule Warriors: Age of Calamity, Sniper Elite 5 and TMNT: Shredder’s Revenge are discussed.
The Centennial Case, Tunic, Gears Tactics, Eternal Threads and Little Cities are among the games we discuss.
It’s probably too long, yet again, but it covers everything from our favourite TV genres to trends in games that we miss.
Ghostwire: Tokyo, Kirby and the Forgotten Land, Tunic, Marvel’s Guardians of the Galaxy and Monster Train.
Dying Light 2, Windjammers 2, Resident Evil 4 VR, NEO: The World Ends With You and more.
25 of your questions about gaming (yes, and Bath restaurants) answered.
Matthew and Samuel each compete to pick the 10 best games on the system for a hypothetical N64 Mini console.
We’re answering 22 more of your questions.
It’s about 30 minutes longer than it should be.
You voted, we suffered! (Not really.) We played 2003’s Ubisoft classic Beyond Good and Evil in full for the first time – but how did it go?
Samuel and Matthew spent a Sunday afternoon playing a stack of Dreamcast games. Here’s how it went.
The podcast fully eats itself and we rate our old GOTY choices. It’s rather deranged, please enjoy.
We went back and played an older, extremely influential Hitman game – but how does it hold up?
Who’s a good hang? Who’s a bad hang? From Tails to Cole Phelps, let’s figure it out.
Two hours where Samuel explains what he did in Japan when he wasn’t making the podcast.
Judge Castle rules on the best and worst console launches, starting with the PSone and ending with the PS5. That’s 20 in total!
Woah, it’s been one whole week since we discussed Resident Evil on this podcast! Time to do a rundown of the best moments from the entire series.
Matthew and Samuel relay their experience trying to solve an escape room in Bath. We weld a list of the top 10 gaming prisons on to the episode.
The sequel to last year’s XL pod on the best video game levels is here, covering 25 different categories.
We discuss the trend of remakes in games and where it began – and whether it’s a good thing for the creative health of games or not.
We dive deeper into the subject of our very first Patreon episode this month, highlighting more of our favourite bosses.
A catalogue of petty grievances from your two hosts, most of which are far too incidental to be taken seriously.
To tie in with a dubious Mario movie, we select 35 of the best moments featuring Nintendo’s iconic platformer hero.
Our key SNES and Mega Drive games take centre stage in this month’s XL episode.
On this silly episode of the podcast, we each throw in 25 things that satisfy us in games.
From Bully to Red Dead Redemption 2, this episode ranks pretty much all of the sandbox games published by Rockstar to date.
Matthew and Samuel each pick some of their favourite levels from across 10+ categories.
We truly struggle through a fairly vanilla chat about two big electronic boxes under our TVs.
Katharine Castle joins us to recount a whole host of great moments from The Legend of Zelda’s history.
In this episode, we boil down the idea of what a 7/10 game is, making it far more confusing than it really should be.
We rank all 22 levels in the Hitman World of Assassination Trilogy.
Rich Stanton joins us to deliver a comprehensive overview of the Metal Gear Solid series.
Matthew and Samuel each recall their 5 best and worst E3 moments.
Samuel discusses 20 old Xbox games he’s enjoyed revisiting on Xbox Series X via backwards compatibility.
We dig in to what makes a classic encounter with a boss.
A ranking of the Mad Max movies by two men who would almost certainly be the oversized comedy sidekicks of rancid villains in Miller’s fictional universe.
This episode is all about Shogun, one of the best TV shows of the year. We also talk a bit about the best TV of the year so far.
Two men who know nothing about the Dune books talk about Denis Villeneuve’s two Dune movies!
Hear about why Dazed and Confused is one of Matthew’s favourite movies, then hear about Samuel’s eternal affection for Lord and Miller’s 21 Jump Street.
We dive into our favourite TV shows from 2023. Was it a great year for TV?
We ranked the 12 movies directed by David Fincher to mark the recent release of The Killer.
Two Giant Men turn Two Giant Film Bros in this list of Marty’s top 10 movies. Apologies in advance.
Matthew delves back into the subject he’s most passionate about: Asian crime fiction. Except this time he expands the remit to thrillers, and even sci-fi!
Our first ever draft episode behind the paywall is a truly chaotic affair – see what you make of this 2.5-hour epic.
After about 8 episodes of promotion, our ranking of the Mission: Impossible movies is finally here!
Matthew and Samuel foolishly try to create power rankings for the first four Indiana Jones movies, The Fate of Atlantis, several 6/10 games, a TV show…
From Inside No. 9 to Matthew’s beloved Northern Exposure, in this episode we each share 10 TV episodes that we love.
From Final Fantasy VII: Advent Children (eugh!) to Russell Crowe’s Robin Hood (oof!), we run through some of our guilty pleasures.
The podcast lunges head-first into self-parody as two large guys in their 30s rank the movies of Christopher Nolan.
Matthew offers a rundown on his favourite films from South Korea.
Samuel babbles about comics for two hours and Matthew politely tolerates him.
Two top 10 lists of our favourite TV shows from 2022.
The podcast goes full Partridge in this ranking of all 25 existing James Bond movies.
Listen to two non-horror fans talk about horror movies for almost three hours!
We’re ranking the Star Wars movies. Apologies in advance for the mountain of bad takes you’re about to endure.
Everything from Blow Out to Christopher Nolan’s Insomnia gets a namecheck in this genre-centric episode.
Who’s the best TV dad?
Two top 10 lists of the best TV shows made since the year 2000 – and much more besides.
Apologies in advance for our terrible takes in this one.
Matthew offers a beginner’s guide to one of his enduring obsessions: Japanese crime fiction.
Here’s what we’ve been playing lately: Stellar Blade, Animal Well, Octopath Traveler 2, Dark Forces Remaster and Pepper Grinder.
What we’ve been playing lately, including Dragon’s Dogma 2, Helldivers 2, Rise of the Ronin, Stellar Blade and some old Command & Conquer nonsense.
Matthew has finally become a big FF7 head, ploughing through Remake in January and now being 50 hours deep into Rebirth.
Some nutritious games waffle to cancel out last week’s nonsense mailbag episode.
The latest on what we’ve been playing, featuring Alan Wake 2, Chants of Sennaar, Super Mario Wonder and more.
We’ve firmly entered silly season, and Matthew has finished Cyberpunk 2077: Phantom Liberty. Does it change his take on the CD Projekt RED FPS/RPG?
Matthew has played 10 hours of Sea of Stars, so we discuss that, the Doom mod My House, Armored Core 6, Paranormasight and Dredge.
A simple but cheerful ‘what we’ve been playing’ joint this week, featuring Exoprimal, Telltale’s comeback game The Expanse, 1998’s Parasite Eve and Pikmin 4.
Kick back, take a seat! Pour yourself a tall glass of water. It’s a simple update on what we’ve been playing lately, featuring Final Fantasy 16 and BG3.
Everything except Zelda is discussed in this week’s episode!
In this week’s episode, Samuel suffers from jetlag and Matthew suffers from living as we recount what we’ve been playing lately.
Hi-Fi Rush, GoldenEye 007 and Fire Emblem: Engage are among the games we’ve been playing lately.
A Plague Tale: Requiem, FF7 Remake, Stay Out Of The House and Taiji are among the games discussed.
Saints Row, Arcade Paradise, Ryse: Son of Rome, Splatoon 3, Star Wars: Rogue Squadron and Escape Academy are the games discussed.
Xenoblade Chronicles 3, Hyrule Warriors: Age of Calamity, Sniper Elite 5 and TMNT: Shredder’s Revenge are discussed.
The Centennial Case, Tunic, Gears Tactics, Eternal Threads and Little Cities are among the games we discuss.
It’s probably too long, yet again, but it covers everything from our favourite TV genres to trends in games that we miss.
Ghostwire: Tokyo, Kirby and the Forgotten Land, Tunic, Marvel’s Guardians of the Galaxy and Monster Train.
Dying Light 2, Windjammers 2, Resident Evil 4 VR, NEO: The World Ends With You and more.
Luigi’s Mansion 3, Resident Evil 3 Remake and more.
Judge Matthew Castle will decide if defendant Samuel Roberts lives or dies.
From The Last of Us Part 2 to Neo: The World Ends With You and Crimson Skies: High Road to Revenge.
The podcast fully eats itself and we rate our old GOTY choices. It’s rather deranged, please enjoy.
The best games of 2003, and loads of bullshit about Matthew’s mini-fridge and Samuel’s week of work experience in the fire brigade.
Two top 10 lists of our favourite games from 2002 and a slew of ridiculous anecdotes about working in Homebase and studying GCSE Drama.
Our biggest episode of the year is here! Two top 10 lists of the best games of the year.
From GTA 3 to Silent Hill 2, 2001 was one of the best years in the history of games. We also share many pointless details of our mixed fortunes as teenagers.
We count down the best games of 2016, a year that brought good news for everyone! Except Microsoft. And Nintendo.
Two top 10s of 2015’s greatest games. Hear about Matthew and Samuel’s friendship emerging during a press trip to Germany.
Two top 10 lists from 2014. Expect a mixture of mag recollections and deep analysis of the games that mattered.
2022 was undoubtedly a blockbuster-deprived year, but it was still a strong 12 months for games in many other ways.
Two top 10 lists of the best games of 2013, in our usual style.
Two top 10 lists of the best games of 2012, in our usual style. Enjoy!
Our GOTY episode is here!
A year that brought us Batman: Arkham City, Skyrim and The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword.
2010, one of the best years of gaming in modern memory.
From Uncharted 2 to Batman: Arkham Asylum.
From Dead Space to Grand Theft Auto 4, 2008 was a phenomenal year in gaming.
From Uncharted: Drake’s Fortune to Crackdown.
Our two top 30 games of the generation lists conclude this week.
Two top 30 lists of the best games on PS4, Xbox One and Wii U from the past 7 or 8 years.
Wow, 2020 was the worst!
From Twilight Princess to Gears of War.
Retro Gamer editor Darran Jones steps into the draft dojo to celebrate Sony’s first gaming handheld device.
Two Giant Men, 20 categories, dubious rules! Time for another draft episode, this time on the subject of video game soundtracks.
Time for our first draft episode of 2024! It’s the turn of the PlayStation, one of the most important consoles in history.
Samuel and Matthew compete to pick the best selection of 10 licensed games, and discuss the wildly inconsistent history of licensed games.
Matthew and Samuel compete to pick the 15 best Nintendo DS games – after an extremely long preamble.
Our first ever draft episode behind the paywall is a truly chaotic affair – see what you make of this 2.5-hour epic.
Matthew and Samuel compete to pick the best 10 games (and one HD collection) that represent the PS3’s somewhat inconsistent library.
Is the Xbox 360 the greatest console ever made? And remember, it’s just a bit of fun! Except where we take what the other person says very personally.
Matthew and Samuel compete to pick the 10 best Capcom games from the developer/publisher’s extensive and dazzling library.
We each try to assemble the ‘dream’ RPG party across 14 categories. Predictably, we each created nightmares instead.
It’s draft revenge time! Who can pick the 10 best games released during the years 2000-2005?
Samuel and Matthew each compete to pick the 10 best PC games released in the years 1990 to 1999.
Matthew and Samuel compete to build the best library for Sony’s fan-favourite handheld device.
Matthew Castle Productions and Big Sammy Holdings are each taking on Game Pass. Who built the best gaming subscription service?
Matthew and Samuel compete to pick the 10 best Wii games.
Who can build the best hypothetical mini console, Matthew, representing GameCube, or Samuel, representing the original Xbox?
Matthew and Samuel each compete to pick the 10 best games on the system for a hypothetical N64 Mini console.
What if Sony released a PS2 Mini? And what if it was good?
Matthew and Samuel can each pick 6 game developers to build a new publisher.
The worst format in podcasting is back! For the first time since 2021, Samuel runs his pre-owned purchases past Judge Castle.
The worst format in British podcasting returns.
Happy, you sickos? It’s the latest entry in our bizarre Games Court format. Those found guilty will die…by Pikmin.
More listeners’ pre-owned purchases go on trial in this latest version of the much-despised Games Court podcast format. Enjoy, and deepest apologies.
Our most interminable podcast format, Games Court, returns! Sorry again for the continued existence of Games Court.
A grim fate awaits anyone who gets on the wrong side of Judge Big Sammy.
This time Judge Big Sammy is making the verdicts.
Judge Castle returns to decide whether listeners must die.
Who will live and who will die?
Judge Matthew Castle will decide if defendant Samuel Roberts lives or dies.
Samuel Roberts stands accused of crimes against good taste.
Beloved guest Jeremy Peel drops by.
With Baldur’s Gate 3 taking over the world, genre expert Jeremy Peel returns to discuss how RPGs have evolved since the days of the Infinity Engine games.
It’s a showdown of revolutionary late ’90s first-person shooters: id Software’s Quake versus Valve’s Half-Life.
Jeremy and Phil stretch the definition of ‘classic’ to its limit in this episode, which explores the flawed but fascinating Jurassic Park: Trespasser.
This foundational title in the turn-based strategy genre is hard as heck these days – but does it stand the test of time regardless?
Jeremy and Phil tackle 1997’s Fallout, arguably the most important PC RPG of that decade.
Westwood’s Blade Runner adventure game comes under the spotlight.
Irrational’s classic sci-fi horror immersive sim System Shock 2.
From The Getaway to Sleeping Dogs, this week Judge Matthew Castle puts the open world games that followed in GTA 3’s wake on trial.
We count down our 10 personal most anticipated games, based on whatever E3 was this year.
We’ve finished Deathloop! Hear about the history of the immersive sim.
Matthew and Rich Stanton build a hall of fame from Resident Evil creator Shinji Mikami’s body of work.
Our task this week is to construct a 10-game hall of fame (or perhaps hall of infamy?) for the Nintendo Wii U.
The wonderful 101st episode of The Back Page attempts to build a 5-game hall of fame from the entire PlatinumGames catalogue.
We try to boil down the complete library of Lucasarts adventure games into five representative titles.
We undertake another grand project: building a library of the very best games for the Nintendo Switch.
Another round of indie game recommendations – and 20 minutes of very welcome Dragon’s Dogma chat.
Plus: another baffling listener question about Yuji Naka.
After last week’s belting return with the GOTY episode, it’s time we roll out some bullshit gaming predictions for 2024.
From Indiana Jones to a Nintendo Switch successor, it’s time for 23 more ridiculous predictions founded on no basis of fact whatsoever.
We revisit our 22 predictions from the start of the year to see just how wrong we were.
11 predictions for the year ahead in gaming, all based on absolutely no information whatsoever.
We put ourselves on trial, discussing everything from N64 games on Switch to PS5 haptics.
It’s all based on very few facts.
It’s a showdown of revolutionary late ’90s first-person shooters: id Software’s Quake versus Valve’s Half-Life.
Jeremy and Phil stretch the definition of ‘classic’ to its limit in this episode, which explores the flawed but fascinating Jurassic Park: Trespasser.
This foundational title in the turn-based strategy genre is hard as heck these days – but does it stand the test of time regardless?
Jeremy and Phil tackle 1997’s Fallout, arguably the most important PC RPG of that decade.
Westwood’s Blade Runner adventure game comes under the spotlight.
Irrational’s classic sci-fi horror immersive sim System Shock 2.
This week’s guest is former Edge editor Alex Wiltshire. Hear about his era of the magazine, as well as his time working at Hello Games and Mojang.
Former Edge editor Margaret Robertson joins us to discuss working on the magazine from 2003-2007 and her career in game development. It’s a good one.
Edge Deputy Editor Chris Schilling joins us for this week’s episode. And yes: we talk about what it means when Edge awards a game a 10.
Hear what goes into an Edge 10, as well as thoughts on Destiny, E3, Street Fighter and the world of videogame consulting.
Former Edge editor Jen Simpkins joins us to discuss some highlights of her career.
Katharine Castle joins us to recount a whole host of great moments from The Legend of Zelda’s history.
Katharine Castle rejoins us to discuss the Xenoblade Chronicles series in enormous detail.
Plus: another baffling listener question about Yuji Naka.
Is it better than Galaxy? Definitely not. Odyssey? Nope. But it is still pretty great.
Andy Kelly is back to discuss his exit from games media after 18 years – and to share eight review scores he got slightly wrong.
Andy Kelly joins us to discuss his love of Sega’s Dreamcast, and his new Alien: Isolation book, Perfect Organism.
What makes a great detective game?
Monster collecting RPG Cassette Beasts just launched! To celebrate, returning pod guest Jay Baylis talks us through the creation of the game.
Jay Baylis joins us to discuss the long history of Pokémon games, subjecting Matthew to his idea of torture.
Please don’t unsubscribe!
Matthew and Rich Stanton build a hall of fame from Resident Evil creator Shinji Mikami’s body of work.
Rich Stanton joins us to deliver a comprehensive overview of the Metal Gear Solid series.
Rich Stanton joins us to discuss the game’s themes and legacy as a PS2 classic.
With a hangover from ninety June livestreams, Matthew and Samuel each deliver their ten favourites from the hype season.
From Doordash ads to a game that looks 90% like BioShock Infinite, these were our highlights from the past week of game reveals.
We count down our 10 personal most anticipated games, based on whatever E3 was this year.
Returning guest Ashley Day tells us about his love of the Sega Saturn, then gives us his ten favourite Sega games of all time.
Our task this week is to construct a 10-game hall of fame (or perhaps hall of infamy?) for the Nintendo Wii U.
We try to boil down the complete library of Lucasarts adventure games into five representative titles.
Another round of indie game recommendations – and 20 minutes of very welcome Dragon’s Dogma chat.
We’re counting down the system’s best games.
Hate Destiny? Fair enough! You may still enjoy the first 24 minutes of this podcast.
Phil Savage joins us for a Yakuza-themed special episode.